Regulatory Law Chambers logo

Abandonment Hearing Many Islands Pipe Lines (Canada) Limited (NEB Decision MHW-001-2018)

Link to decision summarized

Abandonment – Pipeline – Granted


In this decision, the NEB considered Many Islands Pipe Lines (Canada) Limited (“Many Islands”)’ application for the abandonment of the Renaissance – North Bronson Pipeline and associated facilities (the “Pipeline”).

Pursuant to paragraph 74(1)(d) of the National Energy Board Act (the “NEB Act”), and with consideration of section 50 of the National Energy Board Onshore Pipeline Regulations (the “OPR”), the NEB issued Order ZO-M182-005-2018 (the “Order”), granting Many Islands leave to abandon the Pipeline.

Application

Many Islands proposed to abandon the Renaissance – Bronson North Pipeline in place and all associated above ground facilities would be removed. The Pipeline is located primarily in previously disturbed areas within a broader intact forest landscape. Many Islands indicated that abandonment activities would be limited to previously disturbed areas and would be primarily executed within the existing right of way.

Abandonment in Place

Many Islands indicated that it chose to abandon the pipeline in place because pipeline removal would require the use of heavy machinery and increase construction traffic on local roads, which would increase environmental effects and the risk of potential safety issues. The NEB found that Many Islands applied the appropriate rationale for abandoning the pipeline in place.

Indigenous Engagement

The NEB was satisfied with the design and implementation of Many Islands’ consultation activities, as well as its commitment to continue consultation activities throughout the lifecycle of the Project.

The Elizabeth Métis Settlement raised concerns regarding the importance of the lands in the vicinity as well as the cumulative effects of development on traditional lands and practices. The Elizabeth Métis Settlement also had specific requests regarding the reclamation, timing of the abandonment work and requested a site visit.

Many Islands contacted the Elizabeth Métis Settlement to discuss their concerns and committed to providing an updated timeline.

Summary

The NEB granted Many Islands leave to abandon the Pipeline.

The NEB determined that carrying out the abandonment project was not likely to cause significant adverse environmental effects. Given the nature and scope of the Project, and the implementation of the NEB’s conditions, the NEB was of the view that any residual environmental effects would be of limited geographic extent (limited to the Project site), medium-term (in the order of months or years), reversible and of low magnitude.

Related Posts

Auer v. Auer, 2024 SCC 36

Auer v. Auer, 2024 SCC 36

Link to Decision Summarized Download Summary in PDF Appeal – Standard of Review What standard of review applies when we determine whether a regulation is established within the scope of the enabling...